Chapter 1

Set Theory

[63/16%]
Show
LaTeX
Problem 1.1.1

Prove the identities:

?
(a)

(A1×B1)∩(A2×B2)=(A1∩A2)×(B1∩B2)\left(A_{1} \times B_{1}\right) \cap \left(A_{2} \times B_{2}\right)=\left(A_{1} \cap A_{2}\right) \times \left(B_{1} \cap B_{2}\right)

(b)

(A1×B1)\(A2×B2)=[(A1\A2)×B1]∪[(A1∩A2)×(B1\B2)]\left(A_{1} \times B_{1}\right) \backslash \left(A_{2} \times B_{2}\right)=\left[\left(A_{1} \backslash A_{2}\right) \times B_{1}\right] \cup \left[\left(A_{1} \cap A_{2}\right) \times \left(B_{1} \backslash B_{2}\right)\right]

(c)

A×(B∪C)=(A×B)∪(A×C)A \times (B \cup C)=(A \times B) \cup (A \times C)

Problem 1.1.2

Prove that the following identities hold for the universal set XX and A,B,C⊂XA, B, C \subset X.

?
(a)

C\(A∩B)=(C\A)∪(C\B)C \backslash (A \cap B)=(C \backslash A) \cup (C \backslash B).

(b)

C\(A∪B)=(C\A)∩(C\B)C \backslash (A \cup B)=(C \backslash A) \cap (C \backslash B).

(c)

(A∪B)\C=(A\C)∪(B\C)(A \cup B) \backslash C=(A \backslash C) \cup (B \backslash C).

(d)

(A∩B)\C=(A\C)∩(B\C)(A \cap B) \backslash C=(A \backslash C) \cap (B \backslash C).

Problem 1.1.3

Prove that the following identities hold for the universal set XX and A,B,C⊂XA, B, C \subset X.

?
(a)

C\(B\A)=(A∩C)∪(C\B)C \backslash (B \backslash A)=(A \cap C) \cup (C \backslash B).

(b)

(B\A)∩C=(B∩C)\A=B∩(C\A)(B \backslash A) \cap C=(B \cap C) \backslash A=B \cap (C \backslash A).

(c)

(B\A)∪C=(B∪C)\(A\C)(B \backslash A) \cup C=(B \cup C) \backslash (A \backslash C).

(d)

(B\A)\C=B\(A∪C)(B \backslash A) \backslash C=B \backslash (A \cup C).

Problem 1.1.4

Prove that A\B⊂(A\C)∪(C\B)A \backslash B \subset (A \backslash C) \cup (C \backslash B).

?
Problem 1.1.5

Prove that A△B⊂(A△C)∪(C△B)A \triangle B \subset (A \triangle C) \cup (C \triangle B).

?
Problem 1.1.6

Prove that A\(B∩C)⊂(A\B)∪((A∩B)\C)A \backslash (B \cap C) \subset (A \backslash B) \cup ((A \cap B) \backslash C).

?
Problem 1.1.7

Prove that A\B=(AC∪B)CA \backslash B=\left(A^{C} \cup B\right)^{C}.

?
Problem 1.1.8

Prove that A∩(E1∪E2)=(A∩E1)∪(A∩E2∩E1C)A \cap \left(E_{1} \cup E_{2}\right)=\left(A \cap E_{1}\right) \cup \left(A \cap E_{2} \cap E_{1}^{C}\right).

?
Problem 1.1.9

Prove that (A∪B)△(C∪D)⊂(A△C)∪(B△D)(A \cup B) \triangle (C \cup D) \subset (A \triangle C) \cup (B \triangle D).

?
Problem 1.1.10

Prove that (A△B)=AC△BC(A \triangle B)=A^{C} \triangle B^{C}.

?
Problem 1.1.11

Prove that (A∩B)△(C∩D)⊂(A△C)∪(B△D)(A \cap B) \triangle (C \cap D) \subset (A \triangle C) \cup (B \triangle D).

?
Problem 1.1.12

Suppose that E⊂U∪VE \subset U \cup V. Prove that E\(A∪B)⊂(U\A)∪(V\B)E \backslash (A \cup B) \subset (U \backslash A) \cup (V \backslash B).

?
Problem 1.1.13

Suppose that A∩B⊂CA \cap B \subset C. Prove that A\C⊂A\BA \backslash C \subset A \backslash B.

?
Problem 1.1.14

Prove that (A△B)△B=A(A \triangle B) \triangle B=A.

?
Problem 1.1.15

Prove that (A∩C)\(B∩C)=(A\B)∩C=(A∩C)\B(A \cap C) \backslash (B \cap C)=(A \backslash B) \cap C=(A \cap C) \backslash B.

?
Problem 1.1.16

Prove that (A∩C)△(B∩C)=(A△B)∩C(A \cap C) \triangle (B \cap C)=(A \triangle B) \cap C.

?
Problem 1.1.17

Suppose that A⊂CA \subset C. Prove that AC∩BC=(B∪C)C∪(C\(A∪B))A^{C} \cap B^{C}=(B \cup C)^{C} \cup (C \backslash (A \cup B)).

?
Problem 1.1.18

Prove that [(A∩S)∪(B∩SC)]C=(AC∩S)∪(BC∩SC)\left[(A \cap S) \cup \left(B \cap S^{C}\right)\right]^{C}=\left(A^{C} \cap S\right) \cup \left(B^{C} \cap S^{C}\right).

?
Problem 1.1.19

Prove that (A\B)△(C\D)⊂(A△C)∪(B△D)(A \backslash B) \triangle (C \backslash D) \subset (A \triangle C) \cup (B \triangle D).

?
Problem 1.1.20

Let {An}n=1∞\left\{ A_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } and {Bn}n=1∞\left\{ B_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } be arbitrary collections of sets and A=∪n=1∞An,B=∪n=1∞BnA= \cup_{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n}, B=\cup_{n=1}^{\infty } B_{n}. Prove that

A△B⊂⋃n=1∞An△Bn A \triangle B \subset \bigcup _{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n} \triangle B_{n}
?
Problem 1.1.21

Let {An}n=1∞\left\{ A_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } be an arbitrary collection of sets. Prove that

⋂n=1∞An=A1\⋃n=1∞(A1\An). \bigcap _{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n}=A_{1} \backslash \bigcup _{n=1}^{\infty }\left(A_{1} \backslash A_{n}\right) .
?
Problem 1.1.22

Let {An}n=1∞\left\{ A_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } and {Bn}n=1∞\left\{ B_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } be decreasing collections of sets (meaning that An⊃An+1A_{n} \supset A_{n+1} and Bn⊃Bn+1B_{n} \supset B_{n+1} for all n∈Nn \in \mathbb {N} ).

?
(a)

Prove that

⋂n=1∞(An∪Bn)=(⋂n=1∞An)∪(⋂n=1∞Bn). \bigcap _{n=1}^{\infty }\left(A_{n} \cup B_{n}\right)=\left(\bigcap _{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n}\right) \cup \left(\bigcap _{n=1}^{\infty } B_{n}\right) .
(b)

Give an example that equality in (a) need not hold if the sets are not decreasing.

Problem 1.1.23

Let A0A_{0} be a set and let An⊂A0A_{n} \subset A_{0} for all n∈Nn \in \mathbb {N}. Prove that

A0=(A0\A1)∪(A1\A2)∪⋯∪(∩n=1∞An). A_{0}=\left(A_{0} \backslash A_{1}\right) \cup \left(A_{1} \backslash A_{2}\right) \cup \cdots \cup \left(\cap _{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n}\right) .
?
Problem 1.1.24

Let XX be a set and {En}n∈N\left\{ E_{n}\right\}_{n \in \mathbb {N}} subsets of XX. Let A1=E1A_{1}=E_{1} and, for k≥2,Ak=Ek\(E1∪E2∪⋯∪Ek−1)k \geq 2, A_{k}=E_{k} \backslash \left(E_{1} \cup E_{2} \cup \cdots \cup E_{k-1}\right). Prove that {Ak}k=1∞\left\{ A_{k}\right\}_{k=1}^{\infty } is a sequence of pairwise disjoint sets and that ∪k=1∞Ak=∪k=1∞Ek\cup_{k=1}^{\infty } A_{k}=\cup_{k=1}^{\infty } E_{k}.

?
Problem 1.1.25

Let {En}\left\{ E_{n}\right\} be subsets of XX. Prove that

(lim⁡sup⁡En)C=lim⁡inf⁡EnC. \left(\lim \sup E_{n}\right)^{C}=\lim \inf E_{n}^{C} .
?
Problem 1.1.26

Let {An}n=1∞\left\{ A_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } and {Bn}n=1∞\left\{ B_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } be arbitrary collections of sets. Prove that:

?
(a)

lim inf⁡(An∩Bn)=(lim inf⁡An)∩(lim inf⁡Bn)\liminf \left(A_{n} \cap B_{n}\right)=\left(\liminf A_{n}\right) \cap \left(\liminf B_{n}\right).

(b)

lim sup⁡(An∪Bn)=(lim sup⁡An)∪(lim sup⁡Bn)\limsup \left(A_{n} \cup B_{n}\right)=\left(\limsup A_{n}\right) \cup \left(\limsup B_{n}\right).

(c)

lim inf⁡(An∪Bn)⊃(lim inf⁡An)∪(lim inf⁡Bn)\liminf \left(A_{n} \cup B_{n}\right) \supset \left(\liminf A_{n}\right) \cup \left(\liminf B_{n}\right).

(d)

inclusion in (c) can be strict.

(e)

lim sup⁡(An∩Bn)⊂(lim sup⁡An)∩(lim sup⁡Bn)\limsup \left(A_{n} \cap B_{n}\right) \subset \left(\limsup A_{n}\right) \cap \left(\limsup B_{n}\right).

(f)

inclusion in (e) can be strict.

Problem 1.1.27

Let {An}n=1∞\left\{ A_{n}\right\}_{n=1}^{\infty } be an arbitrary collection of sets. Prove that:

?
(a)

∩n=1∞An⊂lim inf⁡An⊂lim sup⁡An⊂∪n=1∞An\cap_{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n} \subset \liminf A_{n} \subset \limsup A_{n} \subset \cup_{n=1}^{\infty } A_{n}.

(b)

each inclusion in (a) can be strict.

(c)

A△(lim inf⁡An)⊂lim sup⁡(A△An)A \triangle \left(\liminf A_{n}\right) \subset \limsup \left(A \triangle A_{n}\right).

(d)

inclusion in (c) can be strict.

(e)

A△(lim sup⁡An)⊂lim sup⁡(A△An)A \triangle \left(\limsup A_{n}\right) \subset \limsup \left(A \triangle A_{n}\right).

(f)

inclusion in (e) can be strict.

Problem 1.1.28

Prove that lim sup⁡n→∞En={x:x∈Ei for infinitely many i}\limsup_{n \rightarrow \infty } E_{n}=\left\{ x: x \in E_{i} \text{ for infinitely many } i\right\}.

?
Problem 1.1.29

Prove that lim inf⁡n→∞En={x:x∈Ei for all but finitely many i}\liminf_{n \rightarrow \infty } E_{n}=\left\{ x: x \in E_{i} \text{ for all but finitely many } i\right\}.

?
Problem 1.1.30

Calculate lim sup⁡En\limsup E_{n} and lim inf⁡En\liminf E_{n} if En=(−1/n,1−1/n]E_{n}=(-1 / n, 1-1 / n].

?
Problem 1.1.31

Calculate lim sup⁡En\limsup E_{n} and lim inf⁡En\liminf E_{n} if En=((−1)n/n,1−(−1)n/n]E_{n}=\left((-1)^{n} / n, 1-(-1)^{n} / n\right].

?
Problem 1.1.32

Calculate lim sup⁡En\limsup E_{n} and lim inf⁡En\liminf E_{n} if En={0,1/n,2/n,…,(n−1)/n,1}E_{n}=\left\{ 0,1 / n, 2 / n, \ldots ,(n- 1) / n, 1\right\}.

?
Problem 1.1.33

Let {En}\left\{ E_{n}\right\} be subsets of XX and let {An}\left\{ A_{n}\right\} be a subsequence of {En}\left\{ E_{n}\right\} obtained by discarding the first NN members, i.e., A1=EN+1,A2=EN+2A_{1}=E_{N+1}, A_{2}=E_{N+2}, etc. Prove that

lim sup⁡En=lim sup⁡An. \limsup E_{n}=\limsup A_{n} .
?
Problem 1.2.1

Let f:X→Yf: X \rightarrow Y and A,B⊂XA, B \subset X. Prove that:

?
(a)

f(A)\f(B)⊂f(A\B)f(A) \backslash f(B) \subset f(A \backslash B).

(b)

inclusion in (a) can be strict.

Problem 1.2.2

Let f:X→Yf: X \rightarrow Y, let A⊂XA \subset X, and B⊂YB \subset Y. Prove that:

?
(a)

If ff is surjective then f(f−1(B))=Bf\left(f^{-1}(B)\right)=B.

(b)

If ff is injective then f−1(f(A))=Af^{-1}(f(A))=A.

Problem 1.2.3

Let f:X→Yf: X \rightarrow Y and A,B⊂XA, B \subset X. Prove that:

?
(a)

ff is injective if and only if f(A∩B)=f(A)∩f(B)f(A \cap B)=f(A) \cap f(B) for all A,BA, B.

(b)

ff is surjective if and only if f(A)C⊂f(AC)f(A)^{C} \subset f\left(A^{C}\right) for all AA.

(c)

f(A)C=f(AC)f(A)^{C}=f\left(A^{C}\right) for all AA if and only ff is bijective.

Problem 1.2.4

Let f:X→Yf: X \rightarrow Y and A,B⊂YA, B \subset Y. Prove that

?
(a)

A⊂BA \subset B implies that f−1(A)⊂f−1(B)f^{-1}(A) \subset f^{-1}(B).

(b)

f−1(A∪B)=f−1(A)∪f−1(B)f^{-1}(A \cup B)=f^{-1}(A) \cup f^{-1}(B).

(c)

f−1(BC)=(f−1(B))Cf^{-1}\left(B^{C}\right)=\left(f^{-1}(B)\right)^{C}.

Problem 1.2.5

Let f:X→Y,A⊂Xf: X \rightarrow Y, A \subset X, and B⊂YB \subset Y. Prove that f(A∩f−1(B))=f(A)∩Bf\left(A \cap f^{-1}(B)\right)= f(A) \cap B.

?
Problem 1.2.6

Let f:X→Yf: X \rightarrow Y, let X0⊂XX_{0} \subset X, let f0f_{0} be the restriction of ff to X0X_{0}, and let E⊂YE \subset Y. Prove that:

?
(a)

f0−1(E)=f−1(E)∩X0f_{0}^{-1}(E)=f^{-1}(E) \cap X_{0}.

(b)

f−1(E)=f0−1(E)∪(f−1(E)∩(X\X0))f^{-1}(E)=f_{0}^{-1}(E) \cup \left(f^{-1}(E) \cap \left(X \backslash X_{0}\right)\right).

Problem 1.2.7

Let f:X→Yf: X \rightarrow Y, let {Ai}i∈I\left\{ A_{i}\right\}_{i \in I} be a collection of subsets of XX, and let {Bi}i∈I\left\{ B_{i}\right\}_{i \in I} be a collection of subsets of YY. Prove that:

?
(a)

f−1(∩i∈IBi)=∩i∈If−1(Bi)f^{-1}\left(\cap_{i \in I} B_{i}\right)=\cap_{i \in I} f^{-1}\left(B_{i}\right).

(b)

f(∩i∈IAi)⊂∩i∈If(Ai)f\left(\cap_{i \in I} A_{i}\right) \subset \cap_{i \in I} f\left(A_{i}\right).

(c)

The equality holds in (b) if and only if ff is injective.

(d)

f−1(∪i∈IBi)=∪i∈If−1(Bi)f^{-1}\left(\cup_{i \in I} B_{i}\right)=\cup_{i \in I} f^{-1}\left(B_{i}\right).

Problem 1.2.8

Let {Ai}i∈I\left\{ A_{i}\right\}_{i \in I} and {Bi}i∈I\left\{ B_{i}\right\}_{i \in I} be subsets of XX. Prove that

?
(a)

(∪i∈IAi)\(∪i∈IBi)⊂∪i∈I(Ai\Bi)\left(\cup_{i \in I} A_{i}\right) \backslash \left(\cup_{i \in I} B_{i}\right) \subset \cup_{i \in I}\left(A_{i} \backslash B_{i}\right).

(b)

Inclusion in (a) can be strict.

Problem 1.2.9

Let f:X→Rf: X \rightarrow \mathbb {R} and let A,B⊂XA, B \subset X. Prove that:

?
(a)

χA∩B=χAχB\chi_{A \cap B}=\chi_{A} \chi_{B}.

(b)

χA∪B=χA+χB−χAχB\chi_{A \cup B}=\chi_{A}+\chi_{B}-\chi_{A} \chi_{B}.

(c)

χA\B=χA−χAχB\chi_{A \backslash B}=\chi_{A}-\chi_{A} \chi_{B}.

(d)

χA∘f=χf−1(A)\chi_{A} \circ f=\chi_{f^{-1}(A)}.

(e)

∣χA−χB∣=χA△B\left|\chi_{A}-\chi_{B}\right|=\chi_{A \triangle B}.

Problem 1.3.1

Prove that every infinite subset of a countable set is countable.

?
Problem 1.3.2

Prove that card⁡[0,1]=card⁡[0,1)=card⁡(0,1)=card⁡[a,b]\operatorname {card}[0,1]=\operatorname {card}[0,1)=\operatorname {card}(0,1)=\operatorname {card}[a, b], if a<ba<b.

?
Problem 1.3.3

Suppose that AA is an infinite set and FF is a finite subset of AA. Prove that card⁡A\F=card⁡A\operatorname {card} A \backslash F=\operatorname {card} A.

?
Problem 1.3.4

Prove that a countable union of finite sets is countable.

?
Problem 1.3.5

Prove that a countable union of pairwise disjoint, countable sets is countable.

?
Problem 1.3.6

Prove that the plane R2\mathbb {R}^{2} is not the union of a countable number of lines.

?
Problem 1.3.7

Prove that card⁡R=card⁡Rn\operatorname {card} \mathbb {R}=\operatorname {card} \mathbb {R}^{n}, for all n∈Nn \in \mathbb {N}.

?
Problem 1.3.8

Let AA be the set of all real numbers in ( 0,1 ) that have infinitely many threes in their decimal expansion. Prove that card⁡A=card⁡(0,1)\operatorname {card} A=\operatorname {card}(0,1).

?
Problem 1.3.9

Prove that for any set A,card⁡A<card⁡P(A)A, \operatorname {card} A<\operatorname {card} \mathbb {P}(A), where P(A)\mathbb {P}(A) is the collection of all subsets of AA, including the empty set and AA itself.

?
Problem 1.3.10

Prove that the collection of ordinals is well-ordered.

?
Problem 1.3.11

Let SS be a subset of a well-ordered set AA and suppose that:

  1. SS contains a0:=min⁡Aa_{0}:=\min A.

  2. If a∈Aa \in A and s(a)⊂Ss(a) \subset S then a∈Sa \in S.

Prove that S=AS=A.

?
Problem 1.3.12

Let AA be a well-ordered set and S={s(a):a∈A}S=\left\{ s(a): a \in A\right\}, ordered with inclusion. Prove that f:A→Sf: A \rightarrow S, defined by f(x)=s(x)f(x)=s(x) is an order isomorphism.

?
Problem 1.3.13

Let A,BA, B be well-ordered sets that are order isomorphic. Prove that there is only one order isomorphism f:A→Bf: A \rightarrow B.

?
Problem 1.3.14

Prove that a well-ordered set cannot be ordered isomorphic to one of its initial segments.

?
Problem 1.3.15

Prove that two different initial segments of a well-ordered set cannot be order isomorphic.

?
Problem 1.3.16

Let λ,μ\lambda , \mu be ordinal numbers, λ=ord⁡A\lambda =\operatorname {ord} A, and let μ<λ\mu <\lambda. Prove that there is a unique a∈Aa \in A such that μ=ord⁡s(a)\mu =\operatorname {ord} s(a).

?
Problem 1.3.17

Let s(λ)s(\lambda ) be the set of ordinal numbers smaller than the ordinal λ\lambda. Prove that λ=ord⁡s(λ)\lambda =\operatorname {ord} s(\lambda ).

?
Problem 1.4.1

Prove that an arbitrary cartesian product of nonempty sets is nonempty.

?
Problem 1.4.2

Prove that the union of a countable collection of countable sets is countable.

?
Problem 1.4.3

Prove that every surjection has a right inverse.

?
Problem 1.4.4

Let RR be a subset of A×BA \times B such that for every a∈Aa \in A there is b∈Bb \in B for which (a,b)∈R(a, b) \in R. Prove that there is F⊂RF \subset R that defines a function from AA to BB, i.e., for every a∈Aa \in A there is exactly one b∈Bb \in B for which (a,b)∈F(a, b) \in F.

?