Section X.2

Measure-Preserving Transformations

[36/100%]
Show
LaTeX
Problem X.2.1

Check that the following transformations preserve Lebesgue measure:

?
(a)

T(x)=(2x) mod 1(x∈[0,1])T(x)=(2 x) \bmod 1 \quad (x \in [0,1]);

(b)

T(z)=zn(z∈C,∣z∣=1),n∈NT(z)=z^{n} \quad (z \in \mathbb {C},\left|z\right|=1), n \in \mathbb {N};

(c)

T(x)=x−1x(x∈R\{0})T(x)=x-\frac{1}{x}(x \in \mathbb {R} \backslash \left\{ 0\right\} ).

Problem X.2.2

Check that the transformation

T(x,y)=((2x) mod 1,12(y+[2x])),(x,y)∈[0,1)×[0,1) T(x, y)=\left((2 x) \bmod 1, \frac{1}{2}(y+\left[2 x\right])\right), \quad (x, y) \in [0,1) \times [0,1)

(the ``baker's transformation'') preserves Lebesgue measure λ2\lambda_{2}.

?
Problem X.2.3

Let X=[0,1)×[0,1),A=(abcd)X=[0,1) \times [0,1), A=\left(\begin{array}{ll}a & b \\ c & d\end{array}\right) be an integer matrix with det⁡A=±1\operatorname {det} A= \pm 1. Define the transformation TA:X→XT_{A}: X \rightarrow X by the formulas TA(x1,x2)=(y1,y2)T_{A}\left(x_{1}, x_{2}\right)=\left(y_{1}, y_{2}\right) for (x1,x2)∈X\left(x_{1}, x_{2}\right) \in X, where

y1=(ax1+bx2) mod 1,y2=(cx1+dx2) mod 1. y_{1}=\left(a x_{1}+b x_{2}\right) \bmod 1, \quad y_{2}=\left(c x_{1}+d x_{2}\right) \bmod 1 .

Prove that

?
(a)

TAT_{A} is one-to-one;

(b)

TAT_{A} preserves Lebesgue measure.

The map (x1,x2)↦(e2πix1,e2πix2)\left(x_{1}, x_{2}\right) \mapsto \left(e^{2 \pi i x_{1}}, e^{2 \pi i x_{2}}\right) lets us identify XX with the torus T2=S1×S1T^{2}=S^{1} \times S^{1} and TAT_{A} with an automorphism of T2T^{2} as a group. This gives us the right to call the transformation TAT_{A} an automorphism of the torus.

Problem X.2.4

Let the map TA:X→XT_{A}: X \rightarrow X be the same as in the previous problem, but with det⁡A∈Z,∣det⁡A∣>1\operatorname {det} A \in \mathbb {Z},\left|\operatorname {det} A\right|>1. Such a map (no longer one-to-one) is called an endomorphism of the torus. Prove that it preserves Lebesgue measure.

?
Remark.
?

Recall the fundamental result: on every compact group GG there exists a nontrivial finite Borel measure μ\mu invariant under translations:

μ(gA)=μ(Ag)=μ(A), \mu (g A)=\mu (A g)=\mu (A),

where A⊂G,g∈G,gA={gx∣x∈A},Ag={xg∣x∈A}A \subset G, g \in G, g A=\left\{ g x \mid x \in A\right\} , A g=\left\{ x g \mid x \in A\right\}. In the case of a metrizable group this measure is uniquely determined (up to a constant factor) and is called Haar measure. Its uniqueness can be used in solving this problem.

Problem X.2.5

Check that the map T(x)=1x mod 1(x∈(0,1])T(x)=\frac{1}{x} \bmod 1(x \in (0,1]) preserves the measure dμ=C1+xdxd \mu =\frac{C}{1+x} d x.

?
Problem X.2.6

Find an absolutely continuous invariant measure

?
(a)

for the map Tn:[−1,1]→[−1,1]T_{n}:\left[-1,1\right] \rightarrow [-1,1], where TnT_{n} is the Chebyshev polynomial (see problems I.2.20 and 1.16 b));

(b)

for the map f:R→Rf: \mathbb {R} \rightarrow \mathbb {R}, where f(x)=1−2x2f(x)=1-2 x^{2}.

Problem X.2.7

Prove that a transformation TT has an invariant (respectively, finite invariant, absolutely continuous invariant) measure if and only if some power Tn(n∈N)T^{n}(n \in \mathbb {N}) of it has this property.

?
Problem X.2.8

Let T:[a,b]→[a,b]T:\left[a, b\right] \rightarrow [a, b] be a strictly monotone continuous transformation. Prove that it has an absolutely continuous invariant measure (in general, an infinite one).

?
Problem X.2.9

Let the transformation T:[a,b]→[a,b]T:\left[a, b\right] \rightarrow [a, b] be piecewise monotone and smooth. Prove that if it has an attracting cycle (see 1), then TT does not preserve any finite measure equivalent to Lebesgue measure.

?
Problem X.2.10

Does there exist a nonzero measure on R\mathbb {R} invariant with respect to all

?
(a)

homotheties Ha:x↦ax(a≠0)H_{a}: x \mapsto a x(a \neq 0);

(b)

affine transformations Aa,b:x↦ax+b(a,b∈R,a≠0)A_{a, b}: x \mapsto a x+b(a, b \in \mathbb {R}, a \neq 0)?

In the case of an affirmative answer, give an example.

Problem X.2.11

Does there exist a nontrivial measure on (0,+∞)(0,+\infty ) invariant with respect to all transformations of the form

?
(a)

Tp:x→xp(p≠0)T_{p}: x \rightarrow x^{p}(p \neq 0);

(b)

Sb,p:x→bxp(p≠0,b>0)?S_{b, p}: x \rightarrow b x^{p}(p \neq 0, b>0)?

In the case of an affirmative answer, give an example.

Problem X.2.12

A measure μ\mu on Rn\mathbb {R}^{n} is called quasi-invariant with respect to shifts if for every a∈Rna \in \mathbb {R}^{n} the condition μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0 is equivalent to the condition μ(A+a)=0\mu (A+a)=0.

Prove that

?
(a)

if a measure μ\mu on Rn\mathbb {R}^{n} is equivalent to Lebesgue measure λn\lambda_{n}, then μ\mu is quasi-invariant with respect to shifts;

(b)

if μ\mu is quasi-invariant with respect to shifts, and the measure of every bounded set is finite, then μ\mu is equivalent to λn\lambda_{n}.

Problem X.2.13

Let TT be a transformation of a set X⊂RnX \subset \mathbb {R}^{n} into itself such that the image TλnT \lambda_{n} of the measure λn\lambda_{n} is absolutely continuous with respect to λn\lambda_{n}, and let ff be an arbitrary summable function on XX. Prove the following statements:

?
(a)

There exists a function f∗∈L1(X)f^{*} \in \mathscr {L}^{1}(X) such that

∫T−1(A)f(x)dx=∫Af∗(x)dx(A⊂X)(1) \int _{T^{-1}(A)} f(x) d x=\int _{A} f^{*}(x) d x \quad (A \subset X) \tag {1}

and f∗f^{*} is uniquely determined up to values on a set of measure zero.

The correspondence P:f↦f∗P: f \mapsto f^{*} is called the Perron-Frobenius operator associated with TT.

(b)

If X⊂RnX \subset \mathbb {R}^{n} is a domain, TT is a smooth one-to-one mapping, with det⁡T′(x)≠0(x∈X)\operatorname {det} T^{\prime }(x) \neq 0(x \in X), then

Pf(Tx)=f(x)∣det⁡T′(x)∣(x∈X). P f(T x)=\frac{f(x)}{\left|\operatorname {det} T^{\prime }(x)\right|} \quad (x \in X) .
(c)

If X=[0,1],TX=\left[0,1\right], T is piecewise differentiable and the set T−1(x)T^{-1}(x) is finite (x∈Xx \in X), then

Pf(y)=∑x∈T−1(y)f(x)∣T′(x)∣ P f(y)=\sum _{x \in T^{-1}(y)} \frac{f(x)}{\left|T^{\prime }(x)\right|}

at all points at which the right-hand side of the equality is defined.

(d)

If X=[0,1],f∈C([0,1])X=\left[0,1\right], f \in C(\left[0,1\right]) and TT is piecewise monotone, then

Pf(x)=ddx∫T−1([0,x])f(t)dt P f(x)=\frac{d}{d x} \int _{T^{-1}(\left[0, x\right])} f(t) d t
(e)

In order for the measure dμ=fdxd \mu =f d x to be invariant with respect to TT, it is necessary and sufficient that for almost all x∈Xx \in X the equality Pf(x)=f(x)P f(x)=f(x) hold.

Problem X.2.14

Let n∈N,Δi=[i−1n,in)(i=1,…,n)n \in \mathbb {N}, \Delta_{i}=\left[\frac{i-1}{n}, \frac{i}{n}\right)(i=1, \ldots , n). Consider the nonnegative functions on [0,1)[0,1) that are constant on the intervals Δi\Delta_{i}. Each such function is given by a vector c=(c1,…,cn)c=\left(c_{1}, \ldots , c_{n}\right) of the values it takes on Δ1,…,Δn\Delta_{1}, \ldots , \Delta_{n}. For clarity, let us denote such a function by the symbol fcf_{c}. Denote the set of nonnegative vectors in Rn\mathbb {R}^{n} by R+n\mathbb {R}_{+}^{n}.

Let T:[0,1)→[0,1)T:[0,1) \rightarrow [0,1) be an arbitrary transformation.

?
(a)

Prove that for every function of the form fc(c∈R+n)f_{c}\left(c \in \mathbb {R}_{+}^{n}\right) there exists a unique function fd(d∈R+n)f_{d}\left(d \in \mathbb {R}_{+}^{n}\right) satisfying the equalities

∫T−1(Δi)fc(x)dx=∫Δifd(x)dx,i=1,…,n \int _{T^{-1}\left(\Delta _{i}\right)} f_{c}(x) d x=\int _{\Delta _{i}} f_{d}(x) d x, \quad i=1, \ldots , n

and moreover the vector dd has the form d=πcd=\pi c, where π=(pij)i,j=1n\pi =\left(p_{i j}\right)_{i, j=1}^{n} is a certain matrix determined by the mapping TT.

The mapping c↦πcc \mapsto \pi c is the discrete (finite-dimensional) analogue of the Perron-Frobenius operator.

(b)

Find the matrix π\pi and prove that pij⩾0p_{i j} \geqslant 0 and ∑1⩽i⩽npij=1\sum_{1 \leqslant i \leqslant n} p_{i j}=1.

(c)

Prove that there exists a vector v∈R+n,v≠0v \in \mathbb {R}_{+}^{n}, v \neq 0, such that πv=v\pi v=v (to this end, consider the sequence of vectors v(m)=1m∑0⩽k<mπku,u∈R+n)\left.v^{(m)}=\frac{1}{m} \sum_{0 \leqslant k<m} \pi^{k} u, u \in \mathbb {R}_{+}^{n}\right).

Problem X.2.15

Let n∈N,Δi=[i−1n,in)(i=1,…,n)n \in \mathbb {N}, \Delta_{i}=\left[\frac{i-1}{n}, \frac{i}{n}\right)(i=1, \ldots , n). A nonnegative function on [0,1)[0,1) that is constant on the intervals Δi\Delta_{i} and takes the values c1,…,cnc_{1}, \ldots , c_{n} on Δ1,…,Δn\Delta_{1}, \ldots , \Delta_{n} is denoted by fcf_{c}, where c=(c1,…,cn)c=\left(c_{1}, \ldots , c_{n}\right).

Let T:[0,1]→[0,1]T:\left[0,1\right] \rightarrow [0,1].

?
(a)

Find the general form of an absolutely continuous measure invariant with respect to TT, if

T(x)={2x for x⩽12,32−x for x>12. T(x)=\begin{cases} 2 x & \text{ for } x \leqslant \frac{1}{2}, \\ \frac{3}{2}-x & \text{ for } x>\frac{1}{2} . \end{cases}
(b)

Indicate some absolutely continuous measure invariant with respect to TT, if

T(x)={x+13 for x⩽23,2−2x for x>23. T(x)=\begin{cases} x+\frac{1}{3} & \text{ for } x \leqslant \frac{2}{3}, \\ 2-2 x & \text{ for } x>\frac{2}{3} . \end{cases}
(c)

Let T(x)=x2T(x)=\frac{x}{2}. Find the fixed point vnv_{n} for the discrete Perron-Frobenius operator (for even nn) and prove the absence of an invariant finite absolutely continuous measure for TT. What do the measures dμn=fvndxd \mu_{n}=f_{v_{n}} d x converge to as n→∞n \rightarrow \infty, if they are normalized by the condition μn([0,1))=1\mu_{n}([0,1))=1?

Problem X.2.16

Let Ω={z∈C∣Im⁡z>0}\Omega =\left\{ z \in \mathbb {C} \mid \operatorname {Im} z>0\right\}. Find an absolutely continuous measure invariant under all conformal automorphisms of Ω\Omega, i.e., transformations T(z)=az+bcz+dT(z)=\frac{a z+b}{c z+d}, where a,b,c,d∈Ra, b, c, d \in \mathbb {R} and det⁡(abcd)>0\operatorname {det}\left(\begin{array}{ll}a & b \\ c & d\end{array}\right)>0.

?
Problem X.2.17

Let P={(x,y)∈R2∣x>0}P=\left\{ (x, y) \in \mathbb {R}^{2} \mid x>0\right\}. For each point (a,b)∈P(a, b) \in P define the transformations La,bL_{a, b} and Ra,bR_{a, b} of the half-plane PP into itself:

La,b(x,y)=(ax,ay+b),Ra,b(x,y)=(ax,bx+y). L_{a, b}(x, y)=(a x, a y+b), \quad R_{a, b}(x, y)=(a x, b x+y) .

Find absolutely continuous measures μL\mu_{L} and μR\mu_{R} on PP invariant under all transformations La,bL_{a, b} and Ra,bR_{a, b}, respectively.

Note that the transformations in question correspond to the left and right shift transformations on the group (under multiplication) of matrices

Mx,y=[xy01],(x,y)∈P, M_{x, y}=\left[\begin{smallmatrix} x & y \\ 0 & 1 \end{smallmatrix}\right],(x, y) \in P,

i.e., to the transformations Mx,y↦Ma,bMx,y;Mx,y↦Mx,yMa,bM_{x, y} \mapsto M_{a, b} M_{x, y} ; M_{x, y} \mapsto M_{x, y} M_{a, b}. The measures μL\mu_{L} and μR\mu_{R} are called the Haar measures (left and right) for this group.

?
Problem X.2.18

Prove that if a transformation T:[a,b]→[a,b]T:\left[a, b\right] \rightarrow [a, b] preserves some finite absolutely continuous measure, then TT is topologically conjugate to some transformation of the same interval preserving Lebesgue measure.

?
Problem X.2.19

Prove that if TT is a homeomorphism of the circle S1S^{1} with irrational rotation number α\alpha (see problem 1.43), then TT is related to the rotation TαT_{\alpha } of the circle by the angle α\alpha (i.e., Tα(e2πix)=e2πi(x+α))\left.T_{\alpha }\left(e^{2 \pi i x}\right)=e^{2 \pi i(x+\alpha )}\right) as follows: h∘T=Tα∘hh \circ T=T_{\alpha } \circ h for some continuous mapping h:S1→S1h: S^{1} \rightarrow S^{1}.

?
Remark.
?

The existence of an invariant measure (not necessarily absolutely continuous) is often established by means of the following Bogolyubov-Krylov theorem [KSF]: for every continuous mapping of a compact set into itself there exists a finite invariant measure.

Problem X.2.20

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

A measurable function ff defined on a set XX with measure μ\mu is called invariant under a transformation T:X→XT: X \rightarrow X if f(Tx)=f(x)f(T x)=f(x) for almost all xx. Prove that for TT to be ergodic it is necessary and sufficient that every invariant measurable function coincide with a constant almost everywhere.

?
Problem X.2.21

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

Are the following transformations ergodic:

?
(a)

T(x)=(x+α) mod 1,x∈X=[0,1),μ=λT(x)=(x+\alpha ) \bmod 1, x \in X=[0,1), \mu =\lambda;

(b)

T(x)=(2x) mod 1,x∈X=[0,1),μ=λT(x)=(2 x) \bmod 1, x \in X=[0,1), \mu =\lambda;

(c)

T(z)=zn,z∈X=S1,μT(z)=z^{n}, z \in X=S^{1}, \mu is Lebesgue measure on the circle (n∈N)(n \in \mathbb {N});

(d)

TT is an automorphism of the torus (see problem 2.3);

(e)

TT is an endomorphism of the torus (see problem 2.4)?

Problem X.2.22

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

Let XX be a set in Rn\mathbb {R}^{n} that is the closure of the set of its interior points, TT a transformation of XX preserving Lebesgue measure. Prove that if TT is ergodic, then for almost every x∈Xx \in X the trajectory of the point xx is everywhere dense.

?
Problem X.2.23

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

Let X=[0,1)nX=[0,1)^{n} be the nn-dimensional torus (n∈N),S(n \in \mathbb {N}), S the shift x↦y=S(x),x \mapsto y=S(x), \quad given by the formula yk=(xk+αk) mod 1\quad y_{k}=\left(x_{k}+\alpha_{k}\right) \bmod 1, k=1,…,nk=1, \ldots , n. For which values of α1,…,αn\alpha_{1}, \ldots , \alpha_{n} is the shift ergodic?

?
Problem X.2.24

The measures are assumed to be finite and normalized (probability measures): μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1.

Prove that the maps of the segment [0,1]\left[0,1\right] into itself given by the formulas

T(x)=(2x) mod 1,S(x)=1−∣2x−1∣, T(x)=(2 x) \bmod 1, \quad S(x)=1-\left|2 x-1\right|,

are metrically conjugate. (Maps T:X→XT: X \rightarrow X and S:Y→YS: Y \rightarrow Y preserving measures μ\mu and vv respectively are called metrically conjugate if there exists a measurable map h:X→Yh: X \rightarrow Y such that hμ=vh \mu =v and S∘h(x)=h∘T(x)S \circ h(x)=h \circ T(x) for almost all x∈Xx \in X.)

?
Problem X.2.25

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

Prove that the map TT of the segment [−1,1]\left[-1,1\right] into itself, preserving the measure μ\mu, is ergodic if

?
(a)

T(x)=1−2∣x∣,μ=12dxT(x)=1-2\left|x\right|, \quad \mu =\frac{1}{2} d x;

(b)

T(x)=1−2x2,μ=1π1−x2dxT(x)=1-2 x^{2}, \quad \mu =\frac{1}{\pi \sqrt{1-x^{2}}} d x;

(c)

T=TnT=T_{n} is the Chebyshev polynomial (see 1.16b)), dμ=1π1−x2dxd \mu =\frac{1}{\pi \sqrt{1-x^{2}}} d x.

Problem X.2.26

A measure μ\mu is called a probability measure if it is finite and μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1.

Prove that if T:X→XT: X \rightarrow X is a transformation preserving a probability measure μ\mu, and ff is a positive function, then ∑kf(Tk(x))=+∞\sum_{k} f\left(T^{k}(x)\right)=+\infty for almost all (with respect to μ\mu) x∈Xx \in X.

?
Problem X.2.27

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

Let T:X→XT: X \rightarrow X be an ergodic transformation preserving a probability measure μ,A\mu , A a measurable subset of XX.

Let εn=0\varepsilon_{n}=0 if Tn(x)∉AT^{n}(x) \notin A, and εn=1\varepsilon_{n}=1 if Tn(x)∈A(n⩾0)T^{n}(x) \in A(n \geqslant 0). Prove that for almost all x∈Xx \in X the limit lim⁡1n∑0⩽k<nεk\lim \frac{1}{n} \sum_{0 \leqslant k<n} \varepsilon_{k} exists (the average number of hits of the trajectory into the set AA), and find it.

?
Remark.
?

The Birkhoff--Khinchin ergodic theorem (see [Bi], [KSF]): let TT be a transformation of a set XX preserving a probability measure μ\mu, and let ff be a measurable function such that ∫X∣f(x)∣dμ(x)<+∞\int_{X}\left|f(x)\right| d \mu (x)<+\infty. Then for almost every (with respect to the measure μ\mu) x∈Xx \in X the limit

lim⁡1n∑0⩽k<nf(Tk(x))=fˉ(x) \lim \frac{1}{n} \sum _{0 \leqslant k<n} f\left(T^{k}(x)\right)=\bar{f}(x)

exists, called the mean value of the function ff along the trajectory of the point xx. Moreover the function fˉ\bar{f} is invariant and ∫Xfˉ(x)dμ(x)=∫Xf(x)dμ(x)\int_{X} \bar{f}(x) d \mu (x)=\int_{X} f(x) d \mu (x). If TT is ergodic, then fˉ\bar{f} turns out to be a constant (see problem 2.20), equal to ∫Xf(x)dμ(x)\int_{X} f(x) d \mu (x) (i.e. the mean value of ff on XX).

Problem X.2.28

A measure μ\mu is called a probability measure if it is finite and μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1. Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0. Probability measures μ1,μ2\mu_{1}, \mu_{2} on XX are called mutually singular if there exists a set A⊂XA \subset X such that μ1(A)=1\mu_{1}(A)=1 and μ2(A)=0\mu_{2}(A)=0.

Let μ1\mu_{1} and μ2\mu_{2} be two probability measures on X,TX, T a transformation ergodic with respect to both μ1\mu_{1} and μ2\mu_{2}. Prove that the measures μ1\mu_{1} and μ2\mu_{2} either coincide or are mutually singular.

?
Problem X.2.29

The measure μ\mu is assumed to be finite and to satisfy the normalization condition μ(X)=1\mu (X)=1 (such measures are called probability measures). Let TT be a transformation of the set XX. A set A⊂XA \subset X is called invariant if T−1(A)=AT^{-1}(A)=A. A transformation TT preserving the measure μ\mu is called ergodic if for every invariant set A⊂XA \subset X one of the following two holds: either μ(A)=0\mu (A)=0, or μ(X\A)=0\mu (X \backslash A)=0.

Consider the irrational shift

S(x)=(x+α) mod 1(x∈[0,1)=X,α∈R\Q). S(x)=(x+\alpha ) \bmod 1 \quad (x \in [0,1)=X, \alpha \in \mathbb {R} \backslash \mathbb {Q}) .

It is ergodic by 2.21a). By the ergodic theorem, for any summable function ff on XX and for almost all x∈Xx \in X the equality

lim⁡1n∑0⩽k<nf(Sk(x))=∫01f(t)dt(1) \lim \frac{1}{n} \sum _{0 \leqslant k<n} f\left(S^{k}(x)\right)=\int _{0}^{1} f(t) d t \tag {1}

holds.

?
(a)

Prove that if f∈C([0,1])f \in C(\left[0,1\right]), then for the shift SS one can assert more, namely that equality (1) holds for every x∈[0,1)x \in [0,1). (First assume that f(0)=f(1)f(0)=f(1), and then consider the general case.)

(b)

Prove that if Δ=⟨a,b⟩⊂[0,1),χΔ(x)=1\Delta =\langle a, b\rangle \subset [0,1), \chi_{\Delta }(x)=1 for x∈Δx \in \Delta, χΔ(x)=0\chi_{\Delta }(x)=0 for x∉Δx \notin \Delta, then

lim⁡1n∑0⩽k<nχΔ(Sk(x))=b−a(2) \lim \frac{1}{n} \sum _{0 \leqslant k<n} \chi _{\Delta }\left(S^{k}(x)\right)=b-a \tag {2}

for all x∈[0,1)x \in [0,1).

If {Sk(x)}\left\{ S^{k}(x)\right\} is replaced by an arbitrary sequence {xk}\left\{ x_{k}\right\}, then property b) is called uniform distribution of this sequence (see [PS], [KN]).

For a uniformly distributed sequence {xk}\left\{ x_{k}\right\} and a function ff continuous on [0,1]\left[0,1\right], a relation analogous to (1) holds:

1n∑k=1nf(xk)⟶n→∞∫01f(t)dt \frac{1}{n} \sum _{k=1}^{n} f\left(x_{k}\right) \underset {n \rightarrow \infty }{\longrightarrow } \int _{0}^{1} f(t) d t

In particular,

1n∑k=1ne2πimxk⟶n→∞0 for any integer m≠0.  \frac{1}{n} \sum _{k=1}^{n} e^{2 \pi i m x_{k}} \underset {n \rightarrow \infty }{\longrightarrow } 0 \text{ for any integer } m \neq 0 \text{. }

This condition is not only necessary but also sufficient for uniform distribution. The latter statement is called Weyl's criterion (cf. problem I.3.9).

Remark.
?

The Birkhoff--Khinchin ergodic theorem (see [Bi], [KSF]): let TT be a transformation of a set XX preserving a probability measure μ\mu, and let ff be a measurable function such that ∫X∣f(x)∣dμ(x)<+∞\int_{X}\left|f(x)\right| d \mu (x)<+\infty. Then for almost every (with respect to the measure μ\mu) x∈Xx \in X the limit

lim⁡1n∑0⩽k<nf(Tk(x))=fˉ(x) \lim \frac{1}{n} \sum _{0 \leqslant k<n} f\left(T^{k}(x)\right)=\bar{f}(x)

exists, called the mean value of the function ff along the trajectory of the point xx. Moreover the function fˉ\bar{f} is invariant and ∫Xfˉ(x)dμ(x)=∫Xf(x)dμ(x)\int_{X} \bar{f}(x) d \mu (x)=\int_{X} f(x) d \mu (x). If TT is ergodic, then fˉ\bar{f} turns out to be a constant (see problem 2.20), equal to ∫Xf(x)dμ(x)\int_{X} f(x) d \mu (x) (i.e. the mean value of ff on XX).

Problem X.2.30
?
(a)

Two points move along a circle, jumping once a second by the same angle, which is incommensurable with π\pi. What fraction of a sufficiently long time interval will both points simultaneously lie on some (fixed in advance) semicircle, if at the initial moment the angle between the points was equal to α\alpha?

(b)

Answer the same question if every second one point moves by an angle β1\beta_{1}, and the other by an angle β2\beta_{2}, where the numbers β1,β2\beta_{1}, \beta_{2}, π\pi are linearly independent over Q\mathbb {Q} (see the definition at the beginning of 4 of Chapter VII).

Problem X.2.31

Let x=∑xk2k,xk∈{0,1}x=\sum \frac{x_{k}}{2^{k}}, x_{k} \in \left\{ 0,1\right\} be the binary expansion of a number x∈[0,1)x \in [0,1). Using the ergodicity of the doubling transformation (see problem 2.21b)), prove that for almost all x∈[0,1)x \in [0,1) the limit lim⁡1n∑0⩽k<nxk\lim \frac{1}{n} \sum_{0 \leqslant k<n} x_{k} exists (the frequency of occurrence of the digit one), and find it. Solve the analogous problem for expansions in a base-pp fraction (cf. problems IX.2.14, IX.2.16).

?
Problem X.2.32

Prove that if a transformation T:X→XT: X \rightarrow X preserving a probability measure μ\mu has the property

lim⁡nμ(A∩T−n(B))=μ(A)μ(B)(A,B⊂X)(*) \lim _{n} \mu \left(A \cap T^{-n}(B)\right)=\mu (A) \mu (B) \quad (A, B \subset X) \tag {*}

(the mixing property with respect to the measure μ\mu), then TT is ergodic.

?
Problem X.2.33

Prove that the transformation

T(x)=(2x) mod 1(x∈[0,1)) T(x)=(2 x) \bmod 1(x \in [0,1))

is mixing, while the irrational rotation (see problem 2.29) is not mixing with respect to Lebesgue measure.

?
Problem X.2.34

Let p∈(0,1),q=1−p,μpp \in (0,1), q=1-p, \mu_{p} be the measure on the interval [0,1]\left[0,1\right] defined as follows: if ε1,…,εn∈{0,1}\varepsilon_{1}, \ldots , \varepsilon_{n} \in \left\{ 0,1\right\} and

Δε1…εn={x∈[0,1]∣xk=εk(k=1,…,n)} \Delta _{\varepsilon _{1} \ldots \varepsilon _{n}}=\left\{ x \in [0,1] \mid x_{k}=\varepsilon _{k}(k=1, \ldots , n)\right\}

(here x=∑xk2kx=\sum \frac{x_{k}}{2^{k}} is the binary expansion of the number xx), then

μp(Δε1…εn)=∏1⩽k⩽np1−εkqεk \mu _{p}\left(\Delta _{\varepsilon _{1} \ldots \varepsilon _{n}}\right)=\prod _{1 \leqslant k \leqslant n} p^{1-\varepsilon _{k}} q^{\varepsilon _{k}}

and the measure is extended to the remaining intervals by additivity. Verify that

  1. the transformation T(x)=(2x) mod 1T(x)=(2 x) \bmod 1 is mixing with respect to the measure μp\mu_{p} (see problem 2.32);

  2. μ1/2=λ\mu_{1 / 2}=\lambda;

  3. the measures μp\mu_{p} and λ\lambda are mutually singular for p≠12p \neq \frac{1}{2};

  4. μp1\mu_{p_{1}} is mutually singular with μp2\mu_{p_{2}} for p1≠p2p_{1} \neq p_{2}.

?
Problem X.2.35

Let aka_{k} be the first digit of the decimal representation of the number 2k(k=0,1,…)2^{k} (k=0,1, \ldots ), i.e., a0=1,a1=2,a2=4,a3=8,a4=1,…a_{0}=1, a_{1}=2, a_{2}=4, a_{3}=8, a_{4}=1, \ldots What is the frequency of occurrence of the digit p∈{1,…,9}p \in \left\{ 1, \ldots , 9\right\} in this sequence?

As is well known, every number xx from the interval (0,1](0,1] can be uniquely represented as a continued fraction

x=1a1+1a2+⋯ x=\frac{1}{a_{1}+\frac{1}{a_{2}+\cdots }}

which is also written as x=[a1,a2,…]x=\left[a_{1}, a_{2}, \ldots \right], where a1=a1(x),a2=a2(x)a_{1}=a_{1}(x), a_{2}=a_{2}(x), a3=a3(x),…a_{3}=a_{3}(x), \ldots are natural numbers. Such a fraction contains finitely many terms only when xx is rational. The finite continued fraction [a1,…,an]\left[a_{1}, \ldots , a_{n}\right] is uniquely written as an irreducible fraction pnqn\frac{p_{n}}{q_{n}}. The value of an infinite continued fraction is understood as the limit of the finite ones:

[a1,a2,…]=lim⁡[a1,…,an]=lim⁡pnqn, \left[a_{1}, a_{2}, \ldots \right]=\lim \left[a_{1}, \ldots , a_{n}\right]=\lim \frac{p_{n}}{q_{n}},

the number pnqn=pn(x)qn(x)\frac{p_{n}}{q_{n}}=\frac{p_{n}(x)}{q_{n}(x)} is called the convergent. It is easily verified that

∣x−pn(x)qn(x)∣⩽1qn(x)qn+1(x) \left|x-\frac{p_{n}(x)}{q_{n}(x)}\right| \leqslant \frac{1}{q_{n}(x) q_{n+1}(x)}

A variety of information about continued fractions can be gleaned from the book [X][\mathrm{X}]. Associated with the expansion of numbers into continued fractions is the Gauss transformation

T(x)=1x mod 1(x∈(0,1]). T(x)=\frac{1}{x} \bmod 1(x \in (0,1]) .

Indeed, let x=[a1,a2,…],y=[a2,a3,…]x=\left[a_{1}, a_{2}, \ldots \right], y=\left[a_{2}, a_{3}, \ldots \right]. Then x=1a1+yx=\frac{1}{a_{1}+y}, from which it follows that y=T(x)y=T(x). Using TT, the numbers ana_{n} are written as follows:

a1(x)=[1x],a2(x)=a1(T(x)),…,an(x)=a1(Tn−1(x)). a_{1}(x)=\left[\frac{1}{x}\right], a_{2}(x)=a_{1}(T(x)), \ldots , a_{n}(x)=a_{1}\left(T^{n-1}(x)\right) .

The Gauss transformation preserves the measure dμ=c1+xdxd \mu =\frac{c}{1+x} d x (see problem 2.5). The measure μ\mu is a probability measure for c=1ln⁡2c=\frac{1}{\ln 2}. The reader can learn about interesting applications of ergodic theory to number theory and continued fractions in [Po].

?
Problem X.2.36
?
(a)

For the Gauss transformation TT, establish the validity, for some C>0C>0, of the inequality

1Cμ(A)μ(B)⩽μ(T−n(A)∩B)⩽Cμ(A)μ(B), \frac{1}{C} \mu (A) \mu (B) \leqslant \mu \left(T^{-n}(A) \cap B\right) \leqslant C \mu (A) \mu (B),

where A,B⊂(0,1],n∈NA, B \subset (0,1], n \in \mathbb {N}. Deduce from this the ergodicity of the transformation TT.

(b)

Prove that for almost all x=[a1,a2,…]x=\left[a_{1}, a_{2}, \ldots \right] the following four statements hold:

  1. the relative frequency with which the number k∈Nk \in \mathbb {N} occurs among the numbers a1,a2,…a_{1}, a_{2}, \ldots equals log⁡2(k+1)2k(k+2)\log_{2} \frac{(k+1)^{2}}{k(k+2)};

  2. lim⁡a1+…+ann=+∞\lim \frac{a_{1}+\ldots +a_{n}}{n}=+\infty;

  3. lim⁡a1…ann=∏(1+1k2+2k)log⁡2k\lim \sqrt[n]{a_{1} \ldots a_{n}}=\prod \left(1+\frac{1}{k^{2}+2 k}\right)^{\log_{2} k};

  4. lim⁡qnn=exp⁡(π212ln⁡2)\lim \sqrt[n]{q_{n}}=\exp \left(\frac{\pi^{2}}{12 \ln 2}\right), where qnq_{n} is the denominator of the nn-th convergent.