Section 4.12

Coupling and Poisson approximation

[8/100%]
Show
LaTeX
Problem 4.12.1

Show that XX is stochastically larger than YY if and only if E[u(X)]≥E[u(Y)]\mathbb {E}\left[u(X)\right] \geq \mathbb {E}\left[u(Y)\right] for any nondecreasing function uu for which the expectations exist.

?
Problem 4.12.2

Let XX and YY be Poisson distributed with respective parameters λ\lambda and μ\mu. Show that XX is stochastically larger than YY if λ≥μ\lambda \geq \mu.

?
Problem 4.12.3

Show that the total variation distance between two discrete variables X,YX, Y satisfies

dTV(X,Y)=2sup⁡A⊆R∣P(X∈A)−P(Y∈A)∣ d_{\mathrm{TV}}(X, Y) = 2 \sup _{A \subseteq \mathbb {R}}|\mathbb {P}\left(X \in A\right)-\mathbb {P}\left(Y \in A\right)|
?
Problem 4.12.4

Show for discrete random variables X,YX, Y that P(X=Y)≤1−12dTV(X,Y)\mathbb {P}\left(X = Y\right) \leq 1-\frac{1}{2} d_{\mathrm{TV}}(X, Y), where dTVd_{\mathrm{TV}} denotes total variation distance.

?
Problem 4.12.5

Show that equality is possible in the inequality of Exercise (4.12.4) in the following sense. For any pair X,YX, Y of discrete random variables, there exists a pair X′X^{\prime }, Y′Y^{\prime } having the same marginal distributions as X,YX, Y such that P(X′=Y′)=1−12dTV(X,Y)\mathbb {P}\left(X^{\prime } = Y^{\prime }\right) = 1-\frac{1}{2} d_{\mathrm{TV}}(X, Y).

?
Problem 4.12.6

Let XX and YY be indicator variables with E[X]=p,E[Y]=q\mathbb {E}\left[X\right]= p, \mathbb {E}\left[Y\right] = q. What is the maximum possible value of P(X=Y)\mathbb {P}\left(X = Y\right), as a function of p,qp, q? Explain how X,YX, Y need to be distributed in order that P(X=Y)\mathbb {P}\left(X = Y\right) be:

?
(a)

maximized,

(b)

minimized.

Problem 4.12.7

The random variable XX is said to be bigger than YY in stop-loss order if

E[(X−a)+]≥E[(Y−a)+] \mathbb {E}\left[(X-a)^{+}\right] \geq \mathbb {E}\left[(Y-a)^{+}\right]

for all a∈Ra \in \mathbb {R}, in which case we write X≥slYX \geq_{\mathrm{sl}} Y. Show that X≥slYX \geq_{\mathrm{sl}} Y is equivalent to: E[X+],E[Y+]<∞\mathbb {E}\left[X^{+}\right], \mathbb {E}\left[Y^{+}\right] < \infty and E[c(X)]≥E[c(Y)]\mathbb {E}\left[c(X)\right] \geq \mathbb {E}\left[c(Y)\right] for all increasing convex functions cc.

?
Problem 4.12.8

The random variable XX is said to be smaller than YY in convex order if E[u(X)]≤E[u(Y)]\mathbb {E}\left[u(X)\right] \leq \mathbb {E}\left[u(Y)\right] for all convex functions uu such that the expectations exist, in which case we write X≤cxYX \leq { }_{\mathrm{cx}} Y.

?
(a)

Show that, if X≤cxYX \leq_{\mathrm{cx}} Y, then E[X]=E[Y]\mathbb {E}\left[X\right]= \mathbb {E}\left[Y\right] and Var⁡[X]≤Var⁡[Y]\operatorname {Var}\left[X\right] \leq \operatorname {Var}\left[Y\right].

(b)

Show that X≤cxYX \leq_{\mathrm{cx}} Y if and only if E[X]=E[Y]\mathbb {E}\left[X\right]= \mathbb {E}\left[Y\right] and X≤slYX \leq_{\mathrm{sl}} Y.