Problem 8.197

Problems and Theorems in Analysis · 1

Show
LaTeX
Problem 8.197

If rr and ss are rational numbers and r+s−3r+s\sqrt{-3} is an integer, then 2r2r and 2s2s must be rational integers and 2r≡2s(mod2)2r\equiv 2s \pmod2; rr and ss need not necessarily be rational integers.

?
Problem 8.197.1

If both ϑ/π\vartheta /\pi and cos⁡ϑ\cos \vartheta are rational, then cos⁡ϑ\cos \vartheta must have one of the following five values:

1,12,0,−12,−1. 1, \quad \tfrac 12, \quad 0, \quad -\tfrac 12, \quad -1 .
?
Problem 8.197.2

Consider the interior angle included between two contiguous faces of a regular solid and call it

T,H,O,D,orI T, \quad H, \quad O, \quad D, \quad \text{or} \quad I

according as the solid is a tetra-, hexa-, octa-, dodeca-, or icosahedron (a hexahedron is a cube). Show that the ratios

TH,OH,DH,IH \frac TH, \quad \frac OH, \quad \frac DH, \quad \frac IH

are irrational.

?
Remark.
?

Show first, using appropriate spherical triangles, that cos⁡T=13\cos T=\tfrac 13, cos⁡H=0\cos H=0, cos⁡O=−13\cos O=-\tfrac 13, cos⁡2D=−35\cos 2D=-\tfrac 35, cos⁡2I=19\cos 2I=\tfrac 19.

Problem 8.197.3

The numbers α1,α2,…,αm\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\ldots ,\alpha_m are called linearly dependent if there exist rational integers a1,a2,…,ama_1,a_2,\ldots ,a_m not all zero such that a1α1+a2α2+⋯+amαm=0a_1\alpha_1+a_2\alpha_2+\cdots +a_m\alpha_m=0. If no relation of this kind exists then α1,α2,…,αm\alpha_1,\alpha_2,\ldots ,\alpha_m are called linearly independent. Thus, if β≠0\beta \neq 0, the numbers α\alpha and β\beta are linearly dependent or independent according as α/β\alpha /\beta is rational or irrational. The number α\alpha is algebraic if there exists an nn (a positive rational integer) such that 1,α,α2,…,αn1,\alpha ,\alpha^2,\ldots ,\alpha^n are linearly dependent.

The numbers (angles) T,HT,H and OO are linearly dependent; in fact

T−2H+O=0 T-2H+O=0

(see 197.2; it can be also proved by elementary geometry). Yet TT and OO are linearly independent.

?
Problem 8.197.4

(continued). Show that T,H,DT,H,D and II are linearly independent. Also H,O,DH,O,D and II are linearly independent, and any linear homogeneous relation with rational coefficients between T,H,O,DT,H,O,D and II can differ only trivially (that is, only by a numerical factor) from the one given in 197.3.

?
Problem 8.197.5

If both ϑ/π\vartheta /\pi and tan⁡2ϑ\tan^2\vartheta are rational then tan⁡2ϑ\tan^2\vartheta must have one of the following five values (regarding ∞=1/0\infty =1/0 as ``rational''):

0,13,1,3,10. 0, \quad \tfrac 13, \quad 1, \quad 3, \quad \tfrac 10 .
?
Problem 8.197.6

With the exception of the four cases n=1,2,4n=1,2,4, and 8, tan⁡2π/n\tan 2\pi /n is irrational for all positive rational integers nn.

?